Can Landlords in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado Say No to Service Animals and Emotional Support Animals?

Jim Stegner • November 19, 2026
Can Landlords in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado Say No to Service Animals and Emotional Support Animals? - Article Banner

In most cases, no. Landlords in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado generally have to allow service animals and emotional support animals, even in a "no pets" rental, under HB26-1045, which took effect August 12, 2026.


That surprises a lot of owners, especially since the federal rules moved the other way this year.


I'm Jim Stegner. I have been managing rentals in Northern Colorado since 2008 through my company, Stegner Property Management, and I own rentals here myself. 


Lately, owners have been asking me:


  • "Do I have to allow an emotional support animal in my Colorado rental?"
  • "Can I charge pet rent for a service animal in my Colorado home?"
  • "What if the ESA letter a renter applicant submitted came from a website?"


Here is how I explain it.


What Is Colorado's Assistance Animal Law (HB26-1045)?


HB26-1045 writes the old federal assistance animal guidance into Colorado law. Governor Polis signed it on May 28, 2026.


Six days earlier, HUD
rescinded its 2020 assistance animal guidance and said it would focus federal enforcement on trained service animals, not untrained emotional support animals.


So if you read a national headline saying landlords can now turn down emotional support animals, that does not apply here. Colorado kept the protections.


What Counts as an Assistance Animal in Colorado?


Under the law, an "assistance animal" is any animal that does work, performs tasks, assists, or provides therapeutic emotional support to a person with a disability. That includes:


  • Service animals, which are trained to do specific tasks
  • Emotional support animals, which provide emotional support that eases a symptom or effect of a disability


An assistance animal is not a pet. Your pet policy does not decide whether it can live in the home. The law on reasonable accommodations does.


Can a Landlord Ask for Documentation?


Yes, within limits. Asking for reasonable documentation of the disability-related need, or working through a good-faith back-and-forth with the tenant, is not discriminatory on its own. The exception is when the disability or the need is obvious.


What you cannot do is demand medical records or a diagnosis. You need enough to confirm there is a disability-related need for the animal. You do not need the person's health history.


Once you have had that chance to talk it through, the law presumes that allowing the animal is a reasonable accommodation.


When Can a Landlord Say No to an Assistance Animal?


Rarely, and only based on that specific animal. The law says the mere presence of an assistance animal is not a direct threat and is not presumed to cause damage.


A landlord may consider
documented, specific conduct by the animal that threatens someone's health or safety or causes substantial property damage.


Breed, size, and weight limits from your pet policy do not apply. And a complete ban on assistance animals is presumed discriminatory.


If your listing or lease says "absolutely no animals," fix that wording now.


Can You Charge Pet Rent or a Pet Deposit for an Assistance Animal?


We don't, and I would not advise it. Colorado already caps pet deposits at a refundable $300 and limits pet rent for actual pets. An assistance animal is not a pet, and Colorado fair housing attorneys have long advised against animal fees for service or emotional support animals.


That does not mean the owner absorbs damage. If the animal damages the home, it can come out of the
regular security deposit like any other tenant damage.


That is one reason our move-in photos and inspections matter so much.


What About Fake Emotional Support Animal Letters?


It is a fair concern. Colorado law already makes it illegal to knowingly misrepresent an assistance animal to get a housing accommodation, with fines that increase for repeat offenses.


But that law is narrow. It requires that the person was warned first and knew the claim was false.


For a property owner, the safer path is not to accuse anyone. Ask for reasonable documentation, keep the conversation in writing, and get advice before you deny a request.


How Does Stegner Property Management Handle Assistance Animal Requests?


We handle it the same way every time. Fair housing means treating every applicant and tenant consistently, and that is how we screen too.


  • We treat the request as a reasonable accommodation request, not a pet application.
  • If the need is not obvious, we ask for reasonable documentation in compliance with the law.
  • We keep the process in writing and do not charge pet fees.
  • We document the home's condition at move-in, so any later damage is clear.


Our leases are reviewed by our attorney and renewed every year, so the language keeps up with changes like this one.


Being pet-friendly also
helps homes rent faster here. Allowing a dog makes a real difference with renters.


FAQs About Service Animals and Emotional Support Animals in Colorado Rentals

Frequently Asked Questions

When did HB26-1045 take effect?

August 12, 2026. It was signed May 28, 2026.


Do I have to allow an emotional support animal in a "no pets" rental in Fort Collins?

Generally, yes. In Colorado, emotional support animals are assistance animals, and allowing one is presumed to be a reasonable accommodation.


Can I require a specific form or certificate?

You can ask for reasonable documentation when the need is not obvious, but not medical records. Rules vary by situation, so talk with an attorney before you require a specific form.


Can the tenant be charged for damage the animal causes?

Yes. Damage beyond normal wear and tear can come out of the regular security deposit.


Is Your Rental Ready for Assistance Animal Requests?


This is general information, not legal advice. For a specific request, talk with a Colorado fair housing or landlord-tenant attorney.


If you own a rental in Fort Collins, Loveland, Windsor, Wellington, Johnstown, Greeley, or nearby, fill out the form below, and we would be happy to talk through how your property handles these requests.


Sources



Share this post

Blog Contact Form

When Should Real Estate Investors Talk to a Property Manager in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
By Jim Stegner • November 5, 2026
Learn why Fort Collins investors should consult a property manager before buying to estimate rental income, prepare for leasing, and avoid costly surprises.
When Is a Good Time to Buy a Rental Property in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
By Jim Stegner • October 22, 2026
Discover when to buy a rental property in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado by evaluating investment returns, rent-ready timelines, and local rental seasons.
Does the 1% Rule Still Work for Rental Properties in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
October 8, 2026
Learn how the 1% rule can help screen rental investments in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado, and why local market knowledge matters when evaluating deals.
How Quickly Do Colorado Landlords Have to Make Repairs in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
By Jim Stegner • September 10, 2026
Learn Colorado landlord repair timelines, including 24- and 72-hour response expectations, documentation, and maintenance best practices.
What Should You Ask Before Buying a Rental Property in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
By Jim Stegner • August 27, 2026
Before buying a rental property in Northern Colorado, ask the right questions about rent, demand, condition, leasing, and expenses to avoid costly mistakes.
What Should New Rental Property Investors Do Before Leasing Their First Home - Article Banner
By Jim Stegner • August 13, 2026
New to rental investing in Northern Colorado? Learn how to price, prepare, market, screen, and lease your first property while avoiding costly mistakes.
What Features Help Properties Rent Faster in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
By Jim Stegner • July 30, 2026
Learn which rental features help homes rent faster in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado, from pricing and pet policies to upgrades renters value most.
What Happens When You Hire a Property Manager in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
By Jim Stegner • July 16, 2026
Learn what happens when you hire a property manager in Fort Collins, from pricing and leasing to maintenance, compliance, and owner communication.
How Can You Enjoy Retirement While Owning Rental Property in Fort Collins and Northern Colorado?
By Jim Stegner • July 2, 2026
Retiring with a rental property? Learn how Fort Collins landlords can keep earning rental income, reduce stress, and enjoy retirement with property management.
How to Price Your Rental Property - Article Banner
By Jim Stegner • May 7, 2026
Price your rental property in Northern Colorado right. Learn how to set rent, avoid vacancy, and maximize income in Fort Collins and nearby cities.
Show More